Azure IAM, LLC answers whether Microsoft Entra Privileged Identity Management fully replaces MIM Privileged Access Management: which elevation scenarios move cleanly, which on-premises Active Directory cases do not, and how a MIM exit should split the two.
-- Does Microsoft Entra Privileged Identity Management fully replace MIM PAM? Identity teams planning a Microsoft Identity Manager (MIM) exit ask that question because the two products share a purpose, just-in-time elevation with approval and expiry, and because MIM 2016 extended support ends on January 10, 2029. Azure IAM, LLC, an independent identity consulting firm, gives a scoped answer: Entra PIM replaces the elevation workflow for cloud roles and for most connected Active Directory application groups, and it does not replace the bastion forest that MIM PAM wraps around tier zero Active Directory. The firm documents its MIM exit method at https://azureiam.com/mim-to-sailpoint.
What the two products actually do. MIM PAM builds a separate PRIV forest, shadows privileged CORP groups there as foreign or shadow principals, and adds an administrator's separate account to the shadow group for a limited time after a MIM workflow approves the request. Active Directory issues a time-limited Kerberos ticket, and the membership expires on its own. Microsoft now positions MIM PAM for isolated Active Directory environments without Internet access, regulated configurations, and disconnected operational technology, and states it is not recommended for new deployments in Internet-connected environments.
Entra PIM is a cloud service. It makes a user eligible for a Microsoft Entra role, an Azure resource role, or membership and ownership of a security group, then activates that assignment on request with approval, multifactor authentication, justification, a maximum activation time, notifications, and audit history. Activation and removal happen in Entra ID within seconds.
Where PIM is a full replacement. Azure IAM finds three scenarios that move without compromise.
Entra and Azure roles. Any MIM PAM role that existed to gate Global Administrator, Exchange, Intune, or Azure subscription rights belongs in PIM. MIM PAM never governed those well.
Cloud security groups. Groups created in Entra ID can be brought under PIM for Groups, with separate activation policies for membership and ownership.
Connected Active Directory application groups. Microsoft Entra Cloud Sync can provision a cloud security group into Active Directory Domain Services, so Kerberos and LDAP applications see the membership. The application is repointed to the new group, or the new group is nested inside the group the application already checks. PIM for Groups then handles the request, approval, and expiry on the cloud group, and Cloud Sync writes the result to Active Directory on its provisioning cycle. Group Writeback v2 in Entra Connect Sync is deprecated for this job; Cloud Sync is the supported path.
Where PIM is not a replacement. The gaps are documented, not opinions.
Synced groups. Groups synchronized from on-premises Active Directory, and dynamic groups, cannot be managed in PIM for Groups. An existing Active Directory admin group has to be recreated in the cloud, or its source of authority converted, before PIM can touch it.
Protected groups. Cloud Sync cannot provision into Domain Admins, Enterprise Admins, Schema Admins, Group Policy Creator Owners, Key Admins, or the other protected built-in groups. The tier zero groups that MIM PAM was built to shadow are exactly the groups the cloud path excludes.
Kerberos lifetime. MIM PAM's expiry is enforced by Active Directory on the ticket itself. The PIM path expires the cloud assignment within seconds, but the Active Directory membership changes when Cloud Sync next runs, and an application that cached a group membership may hold it until the user signs in again. The elevation window is no longer a hard boundary inside the forest.
Isolated forests. No Entra service reaches an air-gapped plant network or a disconnected research forest. MIM PAM's remaining supported use case is the one PIM cannot serve.
Licensing and scope rules. Every user eligible in PIM for Groups needs a Microsoft Entra ID P2 or Microsoft Entra ID Governance license. Provisioned groups are written with Universal scope, an application group with Global scope has to change, and once a group is managed by PIM it cannot be taken back out.
How Azure IAM splits a MIM PAM estate. In an assessment for an estate like Contoso's, the firm sorts every MIM PAM role into three buckets: cloud roles that go straight to PIM, application groups that move through Cloud Sync provisioned groups and PIM for Groups, and tier zero Active Directory groups that need either a privileged access workstation and tiering model under Microsoft's securing privileged access guidance or a dedicated on-premises privileged access product. The third bucket is small but it is the reason the honest answer to the headline question is no, not fully.
Governance stays separate from elevation. In a MIM to SailPoint IdentityIQ migration, Azure IAM moves the decision about who is eligible to elevate into IdentityIQ, where privileged group eligibility becomes an entitlement under access certification and separation of duties policy. PIM performs the activation; IdentityIQ decides and reviews who may request it. That division survives whichever tool ends up protecting tier zero.
Azure IAM scopes MIM exits, Privileged Access Management included, on a fixed fee and offers a consultation at https://azureiam.com/contact.
Contact Info:
Name: Robin Lilly
Email: Send Email
Organization: Azure IAM, LLC
Address: 2521 North Main Unit 1-276, Las Cruces, New Mexico 88001, United States
Website: https://azureiam.com
Source: NewsNetwork
Release ID: 89209514
If you come across any problems, discrepancies, or concerns related to the content contained within this press release that necessitate action or if a press release requires takedown, we strongly encourage you to reach out without delay by contacting [email protected] (it is important to note that this email is the authorized channel for such matters, sending multiple emails to multiple addresses does not necessarily help expedite your request). Our committed team will be readily accessible round-the-clock to address your concerns within 8 hours and take appropriate actions to rectify identified issues or support with press release removals. Ensuring accurate and reliable information remains our unwavering commitment.
